It is a truism bordering on a cliché that the Israeli state and Palestinian resistance organizations have inflicted violence upon one another, claiming the lives of thousands of innocent people on both sides. Media coverage of the carnage has been anything but evenhanded, however. Since the founding of the State of Israel in 1948, Western media have noted and covered and analyzed attacks against Israelis by groups like the PLO and Hamas in painstaking detail, while almost completely ignoring Israeli attacks against Palestinians—and the oppressive high-tech apartheid system Israel created to oppress millions of Palestinians under military occupation—this despite the fact that the death and trauma toll on the Palestinian side has consistently been many times higher.
For the last seven months, for the first time since the Naqba, Palestinian suffering has finally appeared on the radar of the Western press. As usual, this latest spasm of violence has cost many more Palestinian lives—35,000 in Gaza—than Israeli—1,200 on October 7th. (Because the official Gaza death count does not count bodies trapped under the rubble, it is an underestimate.)
That’s basically a 30-to-1 ratio. Now establishment journalists are demanding that everyone, including college student demonstrators, devote equal mention and opprobrium—good dead people on both sides, to coin a phrase.
“Note how one-sided all of this is,” complains Max Boot in The Washington Post. “While denouncing alleged Israeli atrocities, [a statement issued by Columbia University pro-Gaza protesters] has not one word of censure for Hamas or its brutal tactics, which include seizing hostages and perpetrating sexual violence, in addition to committing wholesale murder. Indeed, even though the protesters claim to care about Palestinian lives, they do not denounce Hamas for stealing international aid to build its tunnels and missiles or for using civilians as human shields. They call for Israel to stop fighting but not for Hamas to release its hostages or surrender.” What’s really one-sided, of course, is the loss of life and infrastructure. No one has flattened Israeli cities, razed its schools or demolished its synagogues, graveyards and historic sites. Protesters figure that they don’t need to mention the horrors of October 7th because the media has already done that in great detail.
To give credit where it’s due, Boot’s call for grief-concern parity is a marked improvement. In the past, neither he nor his ilk talked about Israel’s wholesale land theft in the West Bank, its concentration camps and torture facilities, or the IDF’s total lack of concern for Palestinian lives at all.
So let’s be fair. Zionists are absolutely correct that Hamas and October 7th should be condemned. Supporters of the Gazans are also correct that Israel’s insane overreaction, including its war crimes, must be condemned. Said condemnation should be in direct proportion to the scale of the acts.
Israel has slaughtered 30 times more people, for no good reason other than politics and pure entertainment, as Hamas, which did it for no good reason other than spite and attention. Going forward, therefore, Western journalism should look like this:
Hamas is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
Israel is disgusting and must be stopped.
(Ted Rall (Twitter: @tedrall), the political cartoonist, columnist and graphic novelist, co-hosts the left-vs-right DMZ America podcast with fellow cartoonist Scott Stantis. You can support Ted’s hard-hitting political cartoons and columns and see his work first by sponsoring his work on Patreon.)
2 Comments. Leave new
For comparison, shall we intone the entire calendar of charges against the United States? We make all the other countries in the world look like a mother’s loving kiss.
Does anyone have a link to the archive of the “balanced” writings of the execrable propagandist Max Boot on the slow motion genocide of Zionist project against Palestinians over the last 8 decades? That has been the period since the beginning of the major influx of Jewish colonists to Palestine inspired by declarations cooked up by Europeans who, after a millennium of documented persecution of Jews, found a way to get rid of them by blatant PR lies of the sort, “a land without people for a people without a land.”
Palestinians have been paying for the Europe’s historic abuse of Jews, currently at a greatly elevated pace and the risk of literal extinction.
Note. The 30:1 ratio is also an underestimate because a significant fraction of the reported Oct 7 casualties were killed by the Israeli army operating under its Hannibal Doctrine that essentially declares “better an Israeli corpse than a live Israeli hostage.” Hamas, on the other hand, DOES want hostages to trade for the THOUSANDS of Palestinians in Israeli jails, for NO particular reason, under horrid conditions that are only beginning to be reported. Hamas does understand the intrinsic value of LIVE hostages as compared to corpses. Also, NO sex crime complaints have been reported.